In our increasingly polarized world, few topics generate more heated debate than identity—particularly gender identity. But what if our understanding of identity itself is fundamentally flawed?
I recently had the privilege of interviewing Dr. Amethysta Herrick, a scientist with a PhD in biology and genetics who transitioned gender at age 52. Our conversation was nothing short of mind-expanding as she shared insights from her article "The Human System of Identity," which distills two years of deep contemplation on how we become who we are.
What makes Herrick's perspective so valuable is her unique combination of scientific rigor and profound personal experience. After decades working in biology, chemistry, and technology, her gender transition triggered what she describes as "tremendous cognitive changes" that led her to question everything she thought she knew about human identity.
Key insights from our conversation:
We're born with inherent knowledge about ourselves — Herrick describes this as our "origin of identity," comparable to the grain of sand at the center of a pearl. These are fundamental values and preferences we know instinctively but can't necessarily explain the source of.
Identity forms through ongoing negotiation with our environment — Our expression of identity is heavily influenced by seeking safety within our social environment. As Herrick notes, "We have to look around at our social environment and see what we like and what we don't... It's this process of experiencing our social environment and continually revising our ideas of who we are."
Social norms are constantly evolving — What we consider "feminine" or "masculine" varies dramatically across cultures and time periods. Herrick provides a fascinating example: "If I were to tell you somebody who had long flowing hair, elaborate makeup, and high heels... most people today will go, 'well, of course those are feminine,' but if you look at pre-revolution France, those were masculine characteristics."
Our understanding of identity is limited by our desire for simple explanations — "We want an easy answer," Herrick explains. "We want to be able to say, 'well, you have these chromosomes, you have this genetics, so as a result, you have this identity.' We can demonstrate that isn't true."
Perhaps most powerful was Herrick's description of her transition experience: "It was like going from black and white into color..." This vivid metaphor helps even those of us who haven't experienced gender transition understand the profound nature of such a journey.
Watch the full interview to explore fascinating connections between Eastern philosophy, reincarnation, and identity formation that we couldn't fully capture here. Dr. Herrick's insights extend far beyond gender, offering a framework for understanding how all humans develop their sense of self.
[WATCH NOW: The Human System of Identity with Dr. Amethysta Herrick]
P.S. In a world increasingly defined by identity politics, Dr. Herrick's scientific approach offers a rare bridge between traditional values and progressive perspectives. Whether you're struggling to understand someone whose identity differs from yours or seeking deeper insight into your own sense of self, this conversation provides valuable tools for navigating our complex human experience.
Connect with Dr. Amethysta Herrick at amethysta.io or explore her articles at genderidentitytoday.com
Share this post